Absurd Plot Holes and Ridiculous Logic: A Total Fantasy Fail
- "Ayano mind-broke Taro and made him her obedient pet."
Sure, because making someone your “obedient pet” after an entire school’s worth of murders is totally a healthy relationship dynamic. Love that for them. Not suspicious or problematic at all. What a dream scenario. In reality, a guy like Taro, even if mind-broken, would likely be more of a broken, shell-shocked individual, not an adorable puppy dog willing to fetch his girl’s knife. There’s no way he’d just be this compliant zombie without some serious, real-world consequences—psychologically and physically.
- "As the only two students whose corpses weren't found at school, the police would seek them for questioning and Ayano would make up a story about skipping school to go on a date with her boyfriend, and the police would believe her."
Hold up, you're telling me that the police—presumably not complete amateurs—are just going to take this at face value? “Oh, you two were just skipping school together while everyone else mysteriously died? Yeah, totally makes sense. You're free to go, have fun with your dead schoolmates.” The police would absolutely not just take her word for it. The bodies would be a massive red flag, and there would be multiple investigations, not just a simple “oh, I went on a date with my boyfriend” story. Authorities would be on them instantly. It’s like an entire school vanishing into thin air. They’d have more questions than a Game of Thrones plotline.
- "With everyone at school dead, Akademi will close."
Well, no kidding? If all your students and most of your staff are dead, the school’s probably not running for much longer. But here’s the kicker—Akademi would be shut down permanently for criminal negligence, and possibly involve a nationwide investigation, not just a "whoops, the school’s gone." Ayano wouldn’t just skip away like it’s the last day of senior year.
- "Genka and Kocho would have to look for new jobs."
Um, new jobs? Yeah, no. They’d be out of work, alright, but they’d also be under investigation or possibly facing charges themselves for not stopping a massacre. You think the police wouldn’t come for them, too? Genka and Kocho might be looking for a lawyer, not a new job. And if they were involved in any cover-up or had knowledge of Ayano’s activities, their careers would be toast, too. The real job search would be looking for a way to avoid criminal charges.
- "Ayano would most likely continue her education in another school somewhere else, bringing Taro along with her."
Oh, sure, because transferring to another school with a traumatized “pet” and leaving a trail of bodies behind isn’t suspicious at all. You really think Ayano would just waltz into a new school without anyone noticing the massive red flags surrounding her? The authorities would be on the lookout for her, especially if there was even a whiff of her involvement in the murders. She wouldn’t get a free pass to continue her “education” in another school, she’d be on the run or locked up in some psychiatric facility.
- "Info-chan would be too terrified of Ayano to ever contact her again."
This one’s funny. Info-chan? Scared? This girl’s practically a mastermind who’s been running her own game from the shadows. There’s no way she’s terrified of Ayano. If anything, she’d probably turn the tables and use the situation to her advantage, manipulating Ayano and probably making a deal to cover her tracks. She’s not just going to be scared—she’ll use this to secure her own power. If anything, she’s more likely to find a way to exploit Ayano’s psychosis to gain control, not run for the hills.
- "The rivals (except Osana) would have to enroll in other schools."
Yeah, like the rest of the school’s murder victims don’t matter—just shift the rivals to a new school where they can be ignored like it’s a high school musical. If they somehow survived the bloodbath, they would absolutely be questioned, investigated, and possibly relocated for their safety. They wouldn't just get to “transfer schools.” Some might even be witnesses or accomplices in Ayano’s little murder spree. Not like they can just stroll into another school like nothing happened.
- "Megami, who already had suspicions about Ayano, knows exactly why everyone at school died, and who was responsible for it, would most likely begin a crusade to hunt down Ayano and deliver extrajudicial justice."
*Finally, someone with common sense! Except no. Megami? She’s not going full Punisher mode here. She’d be dealing with an entire investigation involving authorities, and “crusading” isn’t exactly high on her list when she’s already got a billion-dollar company to run. The idea that she’d take matters into her own hands in such a high-stakes scenario seems like a plot twist meant to make her appear more badass than she is. It’s unrealistic that a student would be able to operate on such a grand scale, especially after an event this huge. If anything, she’d be in hiding or trying to save herself from getting involved, not hunting down Ayano.
- "Ayano mind-broke Taro and made him her obedient pet."
Sure, because making someone your “obedient pet” after an entire school’s worth of murders is totally a healthy relationship dynamic. Love that for them. Not suspicious or problematic at all. What a dream scenario. In reality, a guy like Taro, even if mind-broken, would likely be more of a broken, shell-shocked individual, not an adorable puppy dog willing to fetch his girl’s knife. There’s no way he’d just be this compliant zombie without some serious, real-world consequences—psychologically and physically.
- "As the only two students whose corpses weren't found at school, the police would seek them for questioning and Ayano would make up a story about skipping school to go on a date with her boyfriend, and the police would believe her."
Hold up, you're telling me that the police—presumably not complete amateurs—are just going to take this at face value? “Oh, you two were just skipping school together while everyone else mysteriously died? Yeah, totally makes sense. You're free to go, have fun with your dead schoolmates.” The police would absolutely not just take her word for it. The bodies would be a massive red flag, and there would be multiple investigations, not just a simple “oh, I went on a date with my boyfriend” story. Authorities would be on them instantly. It’s like an entire school vanishing into thin air. They’d have more questions than a Game of Thrones plotline.
- "With everyone at school dead, Akademi will close."
Well, no kidding? If all your students and most of your staff are dead, the school’s probably not running for much longer. But here’s the kicker—Akademi would be shut down permanently for criminal negligence, and possibly involve a nationwide investigation, not just a "whoops, the school’s gone." Ayano wouldn’t just skip away like it’s the last day of senior year.
- "Genka and Kocho would have to look for new jobs."
Um, new jobs? Yeah, no. They’d be out of work, alright, but they’d also be under investigation or possibly facing charges themselves for not stopping a massacre. You think the police wouldn’t come for them, too? Genka and Kocho might be looking for a lawyer, not a new job. And if they were involved in any cover-up or had knowledge of Ayano’s activities, their careers would be toast, too. The real job search would be looking for a way to avoid criminal charges.
- "Ayano would most likely continue her education in another school somewhere else, bringing Taro along with her."
Oh, sure, because transferring to another school with a traumatized “pet” and leaving a trail of bodies behind isn’t suspicious at all. You really think Ayano would just waltz into a new school without anyone noticing the massive red flags surrounding her? The authorities would be on the lookout for her, especially if there was even a whiff of her involvement in the murders. She wouldn’t get a free pass to continue her “education” in another school, she’d be on the run or locked up in some psychiatric facility.
- "Info-chan would be too terrified of Ayano to ever contact her again."
This one’s funny. Info-chan? Scared? This girl’s practically a mastermind who’s been running her own game from the shadows. There’s no way she’s terrified of Ayano. If anything, she’d probably turn the tables and use the situation to her advantage, manipulating Ayano and probably making a deal to cover her tracks. She’s not just going to be scared—she’ll use this to secure her own power. If anything, she’s more likely to find a way to exploit Ayano’s psychosis to gain control, not run for the hills.
- "The rivals (except Osana) would have to enroll in other schools."
Yeah, like the rest of the school’s murder victims don’t matter—just shift the rivals to a new school where they can be ignored like it’s a high school musical. If they somehow survived the bloodbath, they would absolutely be questioned, investigated, and possibly relocated for their safety. They wouldn't just get to “transfer schools.” Some might even be witnesses or accomplices in Ayano’s little murder spree. Not like they can just stroll into another school like nothing happened.
- "Megami, who already had suspicions about Ayano, knows exactly why everyone at school died, and who was responsible for it, would most likely begin a crusade to hunt down Ayano and deliver extrajudicial justice."
*Finally, someone with common sense! Except no. Megami? She’s not going full Punisher mode here. She’d be dealing with an entire investigation involving authorities, and “crusading” isn’t exactly high on her list when she’s already got a billion-dollar company to run. The idea that she’d take matters into her own hands in such a high-stakes scenario seems like a plot twist meant to make her appear more badass than she is. It’s unrealistic that a student would be able to operate on such a grand scale, especially after an event this huge. If anything, she’d be in hiding or trying to save herself from getting involved, not hunting down Ayano.