How’d your first play through go?

My first play through I saved everybody except Max. I didn’t think it through enough and thought “oh safety in numbers he should go join everyone!” When he was safest where he was on the island. Didn’t want to waste a save life since he was such a minor character.

I shot nick in the pool house even though everybody told me to spare him. Had a feeling he was bad news and was gonna hurt Abigail if I didn’t.

Didn’t cut off Dylan’s arm cause I was too chicken so he turned at the scrapyard.

Shot Caleb with the silver bullets from Abigail and Emma in the lodge.

I think I saved all the Hacketts too except Chris.

How did your first play through go? What did you do different next time?