Is the Eva Grace Smith Madison Document a Hoffman Fraud?

Hello, I’m researching the Caractors Document and came across the “Eva Grace Smith Document”.

I came across two sources one here:

https://archive.bookofmormoncentral.org/sites/default/files/Buddy%20Youngreen%2C%20And%20Yet%20Another%20Copy%20of%20the%20Anthon%20Manuscript%2C%201980.pdf

Which. I says in the footnotes this is a mark Hoffman forgery….

But I came across another source here: https://salemthoughts.com/Topics/Ian-PlatesAndCharacters.pdf

Which says ”print was found in the photograph collection of Eva Grace Smith Madison, which was made sometime between 1879 and 1892.”

So is this a legit source of Reformed Egyptian from the 19th century or is it a Hoffman Fraud?

Hello, I’m researching the Caractors Document and came across the “Eva Grace Smith Document”.

I came across two sources one here:

https://archive.bookofmormoncentral.org/sites/default/files/Buddy%20Youngreen%2C%20And%20Yet%20Another%20Copy%20of%20the%20Anthon%20Manuscript%2C%201980.pdf

Which. I says in the footnotes this is a mark Hoffman forgery….

But I came across another source here: https://salemthoughts.com/Topics/Ian-PlatesAndCharacters.pdf

Which says ”print was found in the photograph collection of Eva Grace Smith Madison, which was made sometime between 1879 and 1892.”

So is this a legit source of Reformed Egyptian from the 19th century or is it a Hoffman Fraud?